Inalienable ≠ inviolable You have to understand what Ellerman means. Inalienable, ...

2026-01-24 01:00:39 UTC

Inalienable ≠ inviolable

You have to understand what Ellerman means. Inalienable, for Ellerman, means consent isn’t a sufficient condition to transfer. That’s it. Just because consent doesn’t transfer the moral right doesn’t necessitate it being inviolable. Another example of an inalienable right is the right to life, but criminal actions can violate this right.

Author Public Key

npub1tjutahja77cwh9l3f8yyg2us8gfe927zhlk9w87fsk7lw24939xqrdladn

Seen on

wss://relay.momostr.pink

Show more details

Published at

2026-01-24 01:00:39 UTC

Kind type

1 Short Text Note

Event JSON

{ "id": "f7acfe4e8818fc40cfd590f9b0d9fe2e3e4d7058c28d76402f374d81451b255d", "pubkey": "5cb8bede5df7b0eb97f149c8442b903a1392abc2bfec571fc985bdf72aa5894c", "created_at": 1769216439, "kind": 1, "tags": [ [ "e", "1734803f0e35093ceeaa8a17fd705622873bd982a5b429d42545b10b180d32b8", "", "reply", "5cb8bede5df7b0eb97f149c8442b903a1392abc2bfec571fc985bdf72aa5894c" ], [ "proxy", "https://mastodon.social/@jlou/115947368583734728", "web" ], [ "e", "54b5c40bfc634745016f4116ca17140829a94c51729805668ac8a24e1a8f76e4", "", "root", "563c984744bf063bdfad99ae51118cdffe3721e819453c4a388071ac88209e8b" ], [ "p", "e3d5a12d648ede45d832fffcf877ae6c2a74dbcba43f17646090b7e6cffe82d8" ], [ "p", "563c984744bf063bdfad99ae51118cdffe3721e819453c4a388071ac88209e8b" ], [ "p", "5cb8bede5df7b0eb97f149c8442b903a1392abc2bfec571fc985bdf72aa5894c" ], [ "p", "590f014d14ad94ad89b8565872089edfb03f1a86ea588918a87c30d6c2aaccdf" ], [ "proxy", "https://mastodon.social/users/jlou/statuses/115947368583734728", "activitypub" ], [ "L", "pink.momostr" ], [ "l", "pink.momostr.activitypub:https://mastodon.social/users/jlou/statuses/115947368583734728", "pink.momostr" ], [ "-" ] ], "content": "Inalienable ≠ inviolable\n\nYou have to understand what Ellerman means. Inalienable, for Ellerman, means consent isn’t a sufficient condition to transfer. That’s it. Just because consent doesn’t transfer the moral right doesn’t necessitate it being inviolable. Another example of an inalienable right is the right to life, but criminal actions can violate this right.", "sig": "315937a0f3f83f7a9b10b25d06985e6637fe68bd3992dd981e49dc498eab6d8efe0a4b6d5817a7a2cc18404aa30ba60dec77f465b894a403a56dc5886a14a1cf" }

J Lou on Nostr: Inalienable ≠ inviolable You have to understand what Ellerman means. Inalienable, ...