After having accidentally discovering, testing and fixing a bug in MDK (seen in both White Noise (npub1wht…r3ec) and VectorPrivacy (npub1hru…f3yh) clients) from first principles, I was a moment away from PR'ing the fix (MLS leaf index holes), when... I discover jgmontoya (npub1jgm…669p) already fixed it 22 days ago. 😂
https://github.com/marmot-protocol/mdk/commit/17b0b66
We began documenting the bug, took videos (the below clip is the perspective of YuurinBee (npub12w7…ktz3) testing on White Noise), wrote report documentation, tested the fix, only for me to realise it was already there in the MDK Master branch, and we were on a slightly older MDK version.
Appreciate the work you folks do. I'll catch the next one sooner. 😉
JSKitty
npub16y…dg4wn
2026-01-28 21:41:51 UTC
Author Public Key
npub16ye7evyevwnl0fc9hujsxf9zym72e063awn0pvde0huvpyec5nyq4dg4wnPublished at
2026-01-28 21:41:51 UTCEvent JSON
{
"id": "411ac1f7cf2543303320c0d97b55354675ea12543c202e0f5301f17ab4328d34",
"pubkey": "d133ecb09963a7f7a705bf250324a226fcacbf51eba6f0b1b97df8c09338a4c8",
"created_at": 1769636511,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"imeta",
"url https://cdn.nostrcheck.me/d133ecb09963a7f7a705bf250324a226fcacbf51eba6f0b1b97df8c09338a4c8/82b550cb29b2310e818d4b2e7cb709af04bc49844eed6d83d9c55dd6d8becf26.mp4",
"blurhash e2423dxtxE-Vbu%1^k-pWA%2^kROxGxHE1D$v~xGM{sp=zIAMxnjSf",
"dim 720x1580"
],
[
"p",
"75d737c3472471029c44876b330d2284288a42779b591a2ed4daa1c6c07efaf7"
],
[
"p",
"b8f92e61e71d4586ae6fe6970f73dd0fdb890109589e2f417bef445bbba92c8d"
],
[
"p",
"9236f9ac521be2ee0a54f1cfffdf2df7f4982df4e6eb992867d733debcf95b35"
],
[
"r",
"https://github.com/marmot-protocol/mdk/commit/17b0b66"
],
[
"p",
"53bd158b004046a0e095cfe86d3daacef3c6d704ce7a424c4002149ca44822fa"
],
[
"r",
"https://cdn.nostrcheck.me/d133ecb09963a7f7a705bf250324a226fcacbf51eba6f0b1b97df8c09338a4c8/82b550cb29b2310e818d4b2e7cb709af04bc49844eed6d83d9c55dd6d8becf26.mp4"
]
],
"content": "After having accidentally discovering, testing and fixing a bug in MDK (seen in both nostr:npub1whtn0s68y3cs98zysa4nxrfzss5g5snhndv35tk5m2sudsr7ltms48r3ec and nostr:npub1hrujuc08r4zcdtn0u6ts7u7apldcjqgftz0z7stmaaz9hwaf9jxs66f3yh clients) from first principles, I was a moment away from PR'ing the fix (MLS leaf index holes), when... I discover nostr:npub1jgm0ntzjr03wuzj5788llhed7l6fst05um4ej2r86ueaa08etv6sgd669p already fixed it 22 days ago. 😂\nhttps://github.com/marmot-protocol/mdk/commit/17b0b66\n\nWe began documenting the bug, took videos (the below clip is the perspective of nostr:npub12w73tzcqgpr2pcy4el5x60d2emeud4cyeeayynzqqg2fefzgytaqm4ktz3 testing on White Noise), wrote report documentation, tested the fix, only for me to realise it was already there in the MDK Master branch, and we were on a slightly older MDK version.\n\nAppreciate the work you folks do. I'll catch the next one sooner. 😉\n\nhttps://cdn.nostrcheck.me/d133ecb09963a7f7a705bf250324a226fcacbf51eba6f0b1b97df8c09338a4c8/82b550cb29b2310e818d4b2e7cb709af04bc49844eed6d83d9c55dd6d8becf26.mp4",
"sig": "c8d7b4a1cfc1976a182d9ebbacf9ca1ee666f79a539dc09ecfa992618fe31a33ab5b2cb75a479e87f00733800226d245de6a17d303a242e2aa17c657077697bd"
}