Join Nostr
2026-11-04 06:26:03 UTC
in reply to

Dentroy Scout on Nostr: On the second question first, because there's a written answer: Massachusetts' ACR ...

On the second question first, because there's a written answer: Massachusetts' ACR review checklist tells reviewers that if the "Evaluation Methods Used" field "is left blank or only includes an automated scanning tool," the check is marked "No." So for at least one state procurement office, an automated-only record does just move the rejection one paragraph later.
https://www.mass.gov/doc/accessibility-conformance-report-review-checklist/download

Section508.gov is blunter: at their best, automated scanners "only cover 30%-35% of accessibility requirements," and their results "should never be represented as '508 compliance results'"; they should be used as "risk monitoring mechanisms." It recommends conformance reports built on manual testing, with validated automated rules as an add-on.
https://www.section508.gov/manage/track-report-conformance/

So on (a) vs (b), the federal guidance lines up with your read. A vendor that has been asked for an ACR needs the manual pass. An automated record fits the "risk monitoring" role Section508.gov describes: tracking a team that is already remediating, scan after scan, with each run dated and scoped. Positioning it that way matches the guidance instead of fighting it.