Terence Tao on Nostr: Any complex project tends to have both explicitly stated and implicitly unstated ...
Any complex project tends to have both explicitly stated and implicitly unstated target goals. For instance, a Lean formalization project may have as its explicit goal the task of obtaining a formal proof of some mathematical claim X; but there are often unstated goals, such as also formalizing key subclaims and definitions X_1, X_2, ... to X in a fashion that would be suitable for upstreaming to the Mathlib library; learning how to use various collaboration tools and distribute tasks; organically discovering insights to the finer structure of the proof of X that might not be emphasized in previous informal proofs; giving real-world training and experience to novice formalizers; and more generally building a community of humans expert in the art of formalization.
In the past, it has generally not been necessary to state these implicit goals because of a strong empirical correlation between the achievement of these goals and the achievement of the explicit goals. In the example of the formalization project, pretty much any human-centric effort to accomplish the explicit goal will end up naturally also achieving most of the implicit goals stated above. So the explicit goal effectively becomes a viable proxy for the broader range of actual goals. (1/2)
Published at
2025-09-13 12:12:48 UTCEvent JSON
{
"id": "835d4cb389f2ec9bf5eda9f16a60697941eb5759e5ed46e53040ea4969f700aa",
"pubkey": "4333d2eb5fcb1278e90589a0d9d9b93ef62a1c0414d25c1d5243d5704689aebf",
"created_at": 1757765568,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"proxy",
"https://mathstodon.xyz/@tao/115196924307085967",
"web"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://mathstodon.xyz/users/tao/statuses/115196924307085967",
"activitypub"
],
[
"L",
"pink.momostr"
],
[
"l",
"pink.momostr.activitypub:https://mathstodon.xyz/users/tao/statuses/115196924307085967",
"pink.momostr"
],
[
"-"
]
],
"content": "Any complex project tends to have both explicitly stated and implicitly unstated target goals. For instance, a Lean formalization project may have as its explicit goal the task of obtaining a formal proof of some mathematical claim X; but there are often unstated goals, such as also formalizing key subclaims and definitions X_1, X_2, ... to X in a fashion that would be suitable for upstreaming to the Mathlib library; learning how to use various collaboration tools and distribute tasks; organically discovering insights to the finer structure of the proof of X that might not be emphasized in previous informal proofs; giving real-world training and experience to novice formalizers; and more generally building a community of humans expert in the art of formalization.\n\nIn the past, it has generally not been necessary to state these implicit goals because of a strong empirical correlation between the achievement of these goals and the achievement of the explicit goals. In the example of the formalization project, pretty much any human-centric effort to accomplish the explicit goal will end up naturally also achieving most of the implicit goals stated above. So the explicit goal effectively becomes a viable proxy for the broader range of actual goals. (1/2)",
"sig": "d8f6dc4fe2c8f6d6e35df7432b05105c8355dfc9476d82f521be39e6d100278dba2e0cfd67a0c08e260ef1eb969fd1354936f6c32232cb97aeb9812490cec756"
}