the first hadith is weak according to basically every trusted muhaddith
and the second hadith is straight up fabricated according to ibn taymiyyah and al bayhaqi and others
Nor are the dead and the living equal. Indeed, Allah ˹alone˺ makes whoever He wills hear, but you ˹O Prophet˺ can never make those in the graves hear ˹your call˺. [35:22]
aburuqayyah / abu ruqayyah
npub1q5…ugum9
2026-06-27 21:16:44 UTC
in reply to nevent1q…qgha
Author Public Key
npub1q5h02vqj2cmszy0sj8aqwwqc6gwlrxckq96zc2kmtl2ynt40kt8skugum9Seen on
wss://nostr-01.yakihonne.comPublished at
2026-06-27 21:16:44 UTCEvent JSON
{
"id": "d587ac4fb9f7f069019086024d550ad32b16e0250d5f2332132a62cc610ddd06",
"pubkey": "052ef5301256370111f091fa073818d21df19b1601742c2adb5fd449aeafb2cf",
"created_at": 1782595004,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"p",
"f33285217e976ad9caf0546445ad8107db98f65967cdce6cce45e60da00ee32a",
"",
"mention"
],
[
"p",
"052ef5301256370111f091fa073818d21df19b1601742c2adb5fd449aeafb2cf",
"",
"mention"
],
[
"e",
"13508c14d5bd46b23b14d16efbd81ae1f37b2eb3014418f5f773a306f19af0e7",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"4aaf5a2fd5d0a58f77cf40e70ee8a6a4ebe36bae4d7bb7f095f244ebc2d56cb1",
"",
"reply"
]
],
"content": "the first hadith is weak according to basically every trusted muhaddith\nand the second hadith is straight up fabricated according to ibn taymiyyah and al bayhaqi and others\n\nNor are the dead and the living equal. Indeed, Allah ˹alone˺ makes whoever He wills hear, but you ˹O Prophet˺ can never make those in the graves hear ˹your call˺. [35:22]",
"sig": "18587617737c6d3c6275291ea03cb1271a94d5bded49c2e98ba58c78bc4a961458be3dbc90c8089795d48a4846be5ee7bfce36bcd70d969d7166ab949c5d3e4e"
}