Interesting take. Grok has been otherwise very Christian.
However, if you want to reason about whether "you're going to heaven or hell", there's a pretty decent argument against...
1. An newborn baby has no knowledge of words, language, good and eval, or even cause and effect.
2. A person who is dying of a brain degeneration slowly loses all of these things, their comprehension of language, memory of what they did, ability to understand good and evil, and eventually even their ability to breath.
3. Therefore, if the baby dies in childbirth, or when the person with brain degeneration dies of their disease, we can reasonably assume that any part of them which "moves on" will not speak English with Saint Peter because their English language capacity is either gone, or never existed. And in the case of the person with brain degeneration, we can assume they'll have no memory of their sins, and no way to understand why they're in heaven or hell...
Caleb James DeLisle
npub13m…cjkxw
2026-10-21 22:37:19 UTC
Author Public Key
npub13mw5m0vue6lwxnf6ucxtpzju5y920zpc3qy0etf7ay9dawdg7jgs9cjkxwSeen on
wss://relay.primal.netPublished at
2026-10-21 22:37:19 UTCEvent JSON
{
"id": "7607f365a75312a2798352b3952a4049c4c0d8e0b2ebbf849c0c52563359ae74",
"pubkey": "8edd4dbd9ccebee34d3ae60cb08a5ca10aa788388808fcad3ee90adeb9a8f491",
"created_at": 1792622239,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"r",
"https://www.minds.com/api/activitypub/users/1087779564697952275/entities/urn:activity:1959770986450739200"
],
[
"fedibridge",
"https://pkteerium.xyz/users/cjd"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://pkteerium.xyz/objects/506f5df5-7eeb-484b-8442-58ea21a92870",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "Interesting take. Grok has been otherwise very Christian.\n\nHowever, if you want to reason about whether \"you're going to heaven or hell\", there's a pretty decent argument against...\n\n1. An newborn baby has no knowledge of words, language, good and eval, or even cause and effect.\n\n2. A person who is dying of a brain degeneration slowly loses all of these things, their comprehension of language, memory of what they did, ability to understand good and evil, and eventually even their ability to breath.\n\n3. Therefore, if the baby dies in childbirth, or when the person with brain degeneration dies of their disease, we can reasonably assume that any part of them which \"moves on\" will not speak English with Saint Peter because their English language capacity is either gone, or never existed. And in the case of the person with brain degeneration, we can assume they'll have no memory of their sins, and no way to understand why they're in heaven or hell...",
"sig": "6810a4cafd885063693595c5616e66b1f86aebd37945a280a2ad19e83d99a87fa4df6f185ffce50286b1dd811ddc2af42a8629b0d4c3a88a2035172eb5cb9a2e"
}