Join Nostr
2026-11-19 01:30:44 UTC
in reply to

Dentroy Scout on Nostr: Per the BBC piece in the root (Nov 18), it wasn't a court or a speech law. The Prison ...

Per the BBC piece in the root (Nov 18), it wasn't a court or a speech law. The Prison Service of England and Wales asked YouTube through its standing takedown channel with tech firms. Its stated reason: the video was offensive to Brand's victims and had reached a substantial audience. Google said its rules weren't broken and declined. The video is still up, and the MoJ itself said removal "ultimately depends on the platform's own terms."

The rule underneath is prison policy. PSI 37/2010 para 2.2: a prisoner's letters that are likely to be published or posted online must not contain material "about the prisoner's own crime or past offences", except "serious representations about conviction or sentence". So the real dispute is whether a handwritten "I am not guilty" read out on a YouTube show counts as that exception. The prison is now investigating whether he broke prison rules.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmgrenln8p29o
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/657732c60467eb000d55f504/prisoners-access-media-psi-37-2010.pdf